Reviewing a risk assessment after an incident or a change

Part of our workplace transport guide: step 2 of 7

Download the review record (Word) (DOCX · 38 KB) · Download the review record (PDF) (PDF · 28 KB)

What does the law say about reviewing a risk assessment?

Regulation 3(3) of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 says:

"Any assessment such as is referred to in paragraph (1) or (2) shall be reviewed by the employer or relevant self-employed person who made it if— (a) there is reason to suspect that it is no longer valid; or (b) there has been a significant change in the matters to which it relates; and where as a result of any such review changes to an assessment are required, the employer or relevant self-employed person concerned shall make them."

HSE's five steps to managing risk end with "Review the controls". HSE's guidance says: "You must review the controls you have put in place to make sure they are working." It adds: "Also consider a review if your workers have spotted any problems or there have been any accidents or near misses. Update your risk assessment record with any changes you make."

The law sets triggers, not a fixed interval. Many sites also review at least once a year, so that an assessment never goes long without a fresh look. That is our suggestion, not a legal requirement.

What counts as a trigger?

Following the regulation and HSE's guidance:

The five review questions

Work through these for each row the trigger touches.

  1. Did the hazard happen the way we expected? If the near miss involved someone the assessment didn't list (a visiting driver, a cleaner, a contractor), the "who might be harmed" column is incomplete.
  2. Was the control in place? Go and look. Is the barrier there, the marking visible, the light working?
  3. Was it being used? A walkway that's there but not used is a different problem from a missing walkway. Find out why people didn't use it; the answer is usually a reason, not carelessness.
  4. Was it enough? If the control was in place and used and the event still happened, the control is too weak for the risk. Look further up the hierarchy: can you separate people and vehicles instead of relying on rules?
  5. What else has changed? New vehicles, new people, new hours, new pressure. The incident often points to a change nobody connected to the assessment.

If the review leads to changes, the regulation says you must make them. Record what you changed, who will do it and by when, and the date you'll check it worked.

A worked example (invented)

This example is invented to show the method. It is not a real site.

A distribution centre has a row in its risk assessment for "pedestrians struck by vehicles at the loading bays". The control listed is "marked walkway along the dock; drivers wait in the drivers' room". On a Tuesday night, a visiting driver walks along the yard side of the trailers to check his load and a reversing shunter stops a metre short of him.

Question Finding
Did it happen as expected? No. The row assumed drivers stay in the drivers' room. Drivers checking their own loads weren't considered.
Was the control in place? The walkway was marked. The drivers' room was open.
Was it used? Not by this driver. Two other drivers that night did the same. They want to watch their trailer being loaded.
Was it enough? No. Nothing gave drivers a safe place to watch from.
What else changed? The night shift started using a second shunter three weeks ago.

Row before: Pedestrians struck at loading bays · employees, drivers · marked dock walkway; drivers wait in the drivers' room.

Row after: Pedestrians struck at loading bays, including visiting drivers checking loads · employees, visiting drivers · marked dock walkway; a marked, barriered viewing point for drivers (HSE: drivers who need to watch loading should do so from a clearly marked, safe position); drivers briefed at the gate; shunter routes reviewed for two-shunter working · action by: night shift manager, two weeks · check: watch three night-shift loads after the change.

How does this connect to the investigation?

If you investigated the incident, the investigation should already have produced actions. HSE's guide to investigation (HSG245) ends with a risk control action plan, and that plan is where the review starts. The review then asks the wider question: does the rest of the assessment still hold?

Our guide to accident and near-miss investigation walks through the four steps.

Use this: a one-page review record

Download the review record (Word) · PDF. Free, no sign-up.

Common questions

How often should a risk assessment be reviewed?

The law sets triggers, not a fixed interval: review it when there is reason to suspect it is no longer valid, or when there has been a significant change (Management Regulations 1999, regulation 3(3)). HSE also suggests a review if workers spot problems or after accidents or near misses. Many sites also review at least once a year as a backstop; that is good practice, not a legal requirement.

Do I have to review it after a near miss?

A near miss is one of the clearest signs that an assessment may no longer be valid, and HSE suggests considering a review after one. Use the five questions: if the control was in place, used and enough, the review can be short. Record that you did it.

Who should review a risk assessment?

The employer who made it is responsible. In practice, the person who owns the area, with the people who work there. They know whether the assessment describes what really happens.

Do I need to tell staff about the changes?

Yes in practice: a control people don't know about can't protect them. Brief the changes at the next shift handover or with a toolbox talk, and update the written record.

What if the review finds nothing needs to change?

Record that you reviewed it, what you checked and the date. A review that confirms a control works is useful evidence too.

Sources

A review asks whether the control was in place and being used. Which control on your site would you most like to see on an ordinary shift? Safety Mapping: a free two-week trial on one camera.

Last reviewed November 2026

All guides