Do you have to consult staff on traffic management?
Yes. HSE's leaflet Consulting employees on health and safety (INDG232) says: "Employers have a duty to
consult with their employees, or their representatives, on health and safety matters." And: "By law, you
must consult all employees on health and safety matters. Some workers, who are self-employed, are still
classed as employees under health and safety law."
There are two sets of rules:
Where a union is recognised, through union safety representatives, under the Safety
Representatives and Safety Committees Regulations 1977. The Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974
says: "It shall be the duty of every employer to consult any such representatives with a view to the
making and maintenance of arrangements which will enable him and his employees to co-operate
effectively in promoting and developing measures to ensure the health and safety at work of the
employees, and in checking the effectiveness of such measures." (section 2(6))
For everyone else, under the Consultation with Employees Regulations 1996: "Where there are
employees who are not represented by safety representatives under the 1977 Regulations, the employer
shall consult those employees in good time on matters relating to their health and safety at work"
(regulation 3).
HSG136 puts it simply: "In workplaces where a trade union is recognised, this will be through union
health and safety representatives. In non-unionised workplaces, you can consult directly or through
other elected representatives." INDG232 adds: "Depending on the circumstances within your workplace, you
may only have to consult under one set of regulations, or you may have to consult under both." And if
what you do already works: "Where you already have existing consultation arrangements that satisfy
health and safety law, there is no requirement to change them."
What does consulting mean?
HSG136: "Consultation involves employers not only giving information to employees, but also listening to
them and taking account of what they say before making health and safety decisions."
People need enough to go on. INDG232: "You must give your employees, or their representatives, the
information necessary to allow them to participate fully and effectively in the consultation."
What should you consult on?
HSG136 lists "risks arising from their work; proposals to manage and/or control these risks; the best
ways of providing information and training."
INDG232's list includes:
"the introduction of any measure which may substantially affect their health and safety at work, eg
the introduction of new equipment or new systems of work, such as the speed of a process line or
shift-work arrangements;"
"the planning and organisation of health and safety training; and"
"the health and safety consequences of introducing new technology."
On a site with vehicles, that includes:
a new layout, one-way system, crossing or walkway;
new vehicles, or a new type of attachment;
new driver rules, speed limits or reversing rules;
shift changes that alter when vehicles and people are in the yard;
contractors' work (HSE's guide to using contractors says to consult on "how the contractor’s work
will affect their health and safety;");
new technology, such as new cameras or vehicle systems: the health and safety consequences.
How to do it well
The people doing the work see things others miss. HSG136: "Employers could ask employees what they think
the hazards are, as they may notice things that are not obvious and may have some good, practical ideas
on how to control the risks." INDG232 lists among the benefits "employees who have extensive knowledge
about their own job and the business;".
Practical ways in:
Walk the route. With drivers, people on foot, and night-shift staff, at the times it's busy.
Use toolbox talks to ask, not only to tell. Each of our free toolbox
talks ends with questions for the team.
Review near misses together. HSG136: "A clear and simple incident-reporting procedure can help to
identify problems early, prevent serious accidents and show how effective your control measures are."
See what is a near miss?
Include everyone affected: agency workers, nights and weekends, and visiting drivers' feedback.
Showing you listened
Write down what people said, what you decided, and why. Then tell them. If you didn't take a suggestion,
say so and give the reason. That is what makes people bother next time. Our guide to safety culture you
can see has more on reading whether people feel heard.
A worked example (invented)
This example is invented to show the method. It is not a real site.
A distribution centre plans a one-way system for its yard. Before deciding, the transport manager walks
the proposed route at 6 am with two shunter drivers and a goods-in operative.
What they said
What changed
The new exit passes a blind corner by the trailer park
A convex mirror and a marked crossing added; trailers no longer parked on the corner
Agency pickers cut across to the canteen there
Walkway extended to the canteen door
Night shift has one shunter, not two
Night-shift version of the plan agreed with the night supervisor
The final plan, and what was changed and why, went up in the drivers' room and was covered at every
shift's toolbox talk the week before it started.
Real cases
We haven't found a recent HSE prosecution involving vehicles that turns on a failure to consult. That
doesn't mean consultation isn't a duty; it is.
Do employers have to consult employees on health and safety?
Yes. By law, employers must consult all employees on health and safety matters, either through union
safety representatives where a union is recognised, or directly or through elected representatives
where it isn't. Some sites need both.
Do we need a union to consult?
No. Where staff aren't represented by union safety representatives, the Consultation with Employees
Regulations 1996 require you to consult them, either directly or through elected representatives.
What do we have to consult staff about?
Anything that may substantially affect their health and safety, such as new equipment, new systems of
work or shift arrangements; health and safety information; the planning of training; and the health and
safety consequences of new technology. On a site with vehicles, that includes layouts, vehicles, driver
rules and routes.
Do we have to consult on new technology such as cameras?
HSE's guidance lists "the health and safety consequences of introducing new technology" as a matter to
consult on. So yes, consult on how it affects people's health and safety before you introduce it.
Do self-employed workers count?
Sometimes. HSE says: "Some workers, who are self-employed, are still classed as employees under health
and safety law."
Sources
The Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, section 2(6).
The Safety Representatives and Safety Committees Regulations 1977.
The Health and Safety (Consultation with Employees) Regulations 1996, regulation 3.
The Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, regulation 7.
Health and Safety Executive (2013). Consulting employees on health and safety: A brief guide to the law (INDG232), revision 2.
Health and Safety Executive (2012). Using contractors: A brief guide (INDG368), revision 1.
Health and Safety Executive (2014). A guide to workplace transport safety (HSG136), 3rd edition, paragraphs 22 and 24–26.
Have you asked your drivers where they think the next near miss will happen? Safety Mapping: a free two-week trial on one camera.