Stevedores and Terminal Operators on One Quay: Who Controls Vehicle and Pedestrian Safety?

Download the shared quay coordination checklist (Word, to fill in) (DOCX · 11 KB) · the checklist to print (PDF, US Letter) (PDF · 32 KB)

This guide goes deeper on the shared-quay side. For what Part 1917 says about traffic lanes, vests and lift trucks, see container terminal and shipyard vehicle safety under OSHA. For the controls themselves around large mobile plant, see keeping people clear of straddle carriers, reach stackers and terminal tractors.

Where does Part 1917 end and Part 1918 begin?

The line is drawn by place and by the equipment doing the lift.

Part 1917, marine terminals. It applies to "employment within a marine terminal", including "the loading, unloading, movement or other handling of cargo, ship's stores or gear within the terminal or into or out of any land carrier, holding or consolidation area" (§ 1917.1(a)). It also says: "All cargo transfer accomplished with the use of shore-based material handling devices shall be regulated by this part." A marine terminal is defined widely, as "wharves, bulkheads, quays, piers, docks and other berthing locations and adjacent storage or adjacent areas and structures associated with the primary movement of cargo or materials from vessel to shore or shore to vessel" (§ 1917.2).

Part 1918, longshoring. It applies "to longshoring operations and related employments aboard vessels" (§ 1918.1(a)). Longshoring operations means "the loading, unloading, moving or handling of cargo, ship's stores, gear, or any other materials, into, in, on, or out of any vessel" (§ 1918.2). Part 1918 repeats the dividing line from the other side: "All cargo transfer accomplished with the use of shore-based material handling devices is covered by part 1917 of this chapter."

In practice, the same stevedoring gang can be under Part 1918 in the hold and on deck, and under Part 1917 on the quay apron and in the yard. Yard tractors, top handlers and people on foot on the quay are a Part 1917 question, whichever company employs them.

The rules follow the work, not the employer. A lasher on the apron is on a marine terminal, whoever signs the paycheck.

What do the vehicle rules ask, and of whom?

Part 1917 puts its vehicle duties on "the employer". On a shared quay there may be several:

Some of these can only be done by whoever controls the layout, such as setting routes and marking walkways. Others fall on each employer for its own people, such as directing its drivers and making sure its own workers wear vests. Which is which on your quay is worth writing down.

At the ship's side on a ro-ro call, Part 1918 adds its own traffic rules aboard the vessel and on its ramps:

The foot of the ramp is where the two parts meet, and where a terminal's traffic plan and a stevedore's ramp plan need to join up.

What is OSHA's multi-employer citation policy?

It is OSHA's enforcement policy for worksites where more than one employer is present, set out in directive CPL 02-00-124, Multi-Employer Citation Policy, effective December 10, 1999. It is not a standard. It describes how OSHA decides which employers to cite.

The directive says: "A two-step process must be followed in determining whether more than one employer is to be cited." First: "The first step is to determine whether the employer is a creating, exposing, correcting, or controlling employer." Then: "Step Two is to determine if the employer's actions were sufficient to meet those obligations."

The four roles, in the directive's words:

Role OSHA's definition
Creating "The employer that caused a hazardous condition that violates an OSHA standard."
Exposing "An employer whose own employees are exposed to the hazard."
Correcting "An employer who is engaged in a common undertaking, on the same worksite, as the exposing employer and is responsible for correcting a hazard."
Controlling "An employer who has general supervisory authority over the worksite, including the power to correct safety and health violations itself or require others to correct them."

OSHA, CPL 02-00-124, Multi-Employer Citation Policy.

Three points from the directive matter on a shared quay:

How the roles apply to a particular terminal depends on the facts, including the lease, the stevedoring contract and who directs the work day to day. That is a question for your own advisers. What any safety lead can do is make sure that, whichever roles apply, the controls are owned, checked and recorded.

How do the two employers split the controls in practice?

What follows is practical advice, not OSHA's position. The aim is that every control has one owner, one named contact and a way to check it.

Traffic routes, crossings and walkways. Usually set by whoever controls the terminal layout. The other employer's job is to brief its people on them, use them, and report where they don't work.

Exclusion zones. Fixed zones, such as under quay cranes and around reefer stacks, sit naturally with the layout owner. Zones that move with the operation, such as the working area of a gang during lashing or a block where plant is stopped for people on foot, are often set by whoever runs that operation. Agree how a temporary zone is opened, marked and closed, and who confirms it is clear before plant restarts.

Speed. Limits are set by the layout owner. Each employer enforces them with its own drivers.

Lighting. The layout owner maintains it. Anyone who finds a dark crossing or stack end reports it the same shift.

Visiting truckers. Agree who briefs them at the gate, where they wait while being loaded, and who deals with a driver who leaves the cab in the wrong place.

Vessel-call briefings. A short joint briefing before each call: berth, crane plan, which blocks are working, any ro-ro ramp plan, temporary exclusion zones, radio channels, and the stop signal.

Handover between gangs and shifts. What changed on the quay since the last shift: a moved stack, a closed lane, a near miss. Write it down; don't rely on memory at changeover.

Radios and stop-work. One agreed signal that stops plant in a block, which anyone from either employer can give, and a rule that nobody is criticized for using it.

Inductions for casual and hiring-hall labor. People who don't work the terminal every week need the routes, crossings and stop signal before they start, not on the way to the berth.

Near-miss reporting. Agree that a near miss involving both employers is reported once, shared with both, and reviewed together. Our free near-miss log has the fields to start with.

On a shared quay the gap is rarely a missing rule. It is a rule each employer thought the other one owned.

What does this look like in practice?

A container terminal operator and a stevedoring company work a two-berth quay. The terminal runs the yard tractors and the gate. The stevedore supplies the lashing gangs and the checkers.

How do both employers see whether it is working?

Written agreements are the easy part. The useful question is what happens on a normal shift, especially nights and busy vessel calls. Walk the quay at a time you don't usually see it, and record what you saw, with the time and the place. Our guide to proving your traffic controls work covers what a useful record looks like.

Fixed cameras can help with this. RoboK SiteLens runs on a terminal's existing cameras and records near misses between people and vehicles, people in vehicle routes, entries to exclusion zones you define and high-visibility vests, each with the time, the zone and the clip, so both employers can discuss the same facts at their review. Speed monitoring is also available. It works on the quay and in the terminal, not inside vessels. It doesn't warn drivers in the cab and doesn't detect crane lifts or suspended loads. Safety Mapping is a free two-week trial on one camera, ours on its own 4G or one of yours, and is open to US sites.

Common questions

Does OSHA Part 1917 or Part 1918 apply to stevedores?

It depends on where the work is done and with what equipment. Part 1918 applies to longshoring operations and related employments aboard vessels. Part 1917 applies to employment within a marine terminal, and covers all cargo transfer done with shore-based material handling devices. A stevedoring gang can be under Part 1918 aboard the vessel and Part 1917 on the quay and in the yard.

What is a controlling employer under OSHA?

OSHA's multi-employer citation policy (CPL 02-00-124) defines a controlling employer as "An employer who has general supervisory authority over the worksite, including the power to correct safety and health violations itself or require others to correct them." It must exercise reasonable care to prevent and detect violations on the site. Whether a terminal operator or a stevedore is a controlling employer depends on the facts of the site.

Can OSHA cite both the terminal operator and the stevedore for the same hazard?

OSHA's multi-employer citation policy allows more than one employer to be cited where each is a creating, exposing, correcting or controlling employer and its actions were not sufficient to meet its obligations. An employer may have more than one role. How it applies to a particular site is a question for legal advice.

Who is responsible for traffic routes on a marine terminal?

Part 1917 requires that "Vehicular routes, traffic rules, and parking areas shall be established, identified, and used" (§ 1917.44(f)). In practice, routes are usually set by whoever controls the terminal layout, and each employer directs its own drivers and briefs its own people. Write down who owns each part.

What does OSHA require on ro-ro ramps?

Part 1918 requires an organized system of vehicular and pedestrian traffic control at each entrance and exit ramp and on ramps within the vessel as traffic flow warrants. Ramps also used by people on foot must provide physical separation or a positive means to stop vehicles and pedestrians using the ramp at the same time (§ 1918.86).

What should a vessel-call safety briefing cover on a shared quay?

The berth and crane plan, which yard blocks are working, any ro-ro ramp plan, temporary exclusion zones and who opens and closes them, routes and crossings, radio channels, the stop-work signal, and how near misses will be reported. Both employers' supervisors should attend.

References

Two employers, one quay, one set of crossings. Two weeks on one camera gives you both the same facts about what happens there. Safety Mapping: a free two-week trial on one camera.

Last checked November 2026

All guides