Every site has one. A line of scuffed paint, a gap in the planting, a gate propped open, a strip of yard where the dust has been walked flat. The walkway is ten metres away, freshly painted, and nobody uses it.
The usual response is a sign, a reminder at the toolbox talk, and sometimes a disciplinary conversation. The shortcut carries on.
A desire line is the path people actually take between two places, as opposed to the one that was laid out for them. The term comes from town planning, where worn tracks across parks and verges show designers where the paths should have gone.
HSE uses the same idea in its guide to workplace transport. On segregating pedestrians from vehicles, it says:
"Consider making pedestrian traffic routes correspond to the paths people would naturally follow when walking across a site (often known as 'desire lines')." (HSG136, paragraph 47)
It is a quietly radical sentence. It asks the designer to follow the walker, not the other way round.
Walkways are usually drawn where there is room for them: along a wall, around the edge of a yard, on the side of the building the planner was looking at. That is a reasonable way to draw a plan. It is not always where people need to go.
The canteen moves. A new door is cut. The drivers' room is on the far side of the trailers. The toilets are closer by the direct route. Each change is small, and each one bends the desire line a little further from the painted one.
Then there is time. A route that adds two minutes is nothing once. Across a shift, with a supervisor waiting and a trailer due out, the shorter route looks like the sensible choice. Usually it is the sensible choice, until the one time a vehicle is there.
HSE's guidance on human factors, Reducing error and influencing behaviour (HSG48), separates errors from violations: deliberate departures from a rule. It is careful not to treat all violations alike. "Violations are divided into three categories: routine, situational and exceptional."
That distinction matters here. A routine violation is one that has become normal: everyone does it, nobody remarks on it. A situational one happens because the job, as set up, makes the rule hard to follow. Most shortcuts across a yard are one or the other. Very few are the exceptional, one-off kind. And neither routine nor situational shortcuts are fixed by telling individuals to try harder, because the cause sits in the work, not the person.
James Reason's Human Error (1990) gave the field the clearest early account of why errors and violations need different responses. Erik Hollnagel's The ETTO Principle (2009) describes the efficiency–thoroughness trade-off: people constantly balance doing things quickly against doing them thoroughly, and mostly get it right. A shortcut is that trade-off made visible on the ground.
The same thread runs through work on work-as-imagined and work-as-done and on normalisation of deviance: the gap between the plan and the practice is information, and a gap that persists becomes the new normal.
A shortcut on a quiet day shift, in daylight, with one vehicle moving, is a different risk from the same shortcut at night, at peak, with three shunters working. A visiting driver taking it is different again: they don't know which way the vehicles come from.
So the desire line itself is worth recording as a hazard, with the conditions that change it. The same worn path can be harmless at 10 in the morning and the most dangerous place on site at 2 at night.
Walk the site and look for the worn path. Don't start with who uses it. Start with where it goes, and why that route is quicker.
Then there are two honest choices. Move the walkway, or the crossing, onto the desire line. Or, where the desire line runs somewhere genuinely dangerous, make the shortcut physically harder: HSE suggests barriers or rails to stop people crossing at dangerous points, and deterrent paving to guide them to the crossing (HSG136, paragraph 52).
What rarely works is a third option: leaving the layout as it is and relying on a sign.
The question is not who keeps cutting across. It is where the worn path goes, and why.
Good site design has always followed people. What is changing is how easily we can see where they actually go: across a whole shift, not just the hour someone happens to be watching. The sites that use that to move a walkway, rather than to write another warning, will find people using it.
The route people actually take between two places, as opposed to the one laid out for them. HSE's workplace transport guidance (HSG136, paragraph 47) suggests making pedestrian routes follow them.
If it breaks a site rule, technically yes. HSE's guidance (HSG48) divides violations into routine, situational and exceptional. Most shortcuts are routine or situational: they come from how the site and the work are set up, so the fix is usually in the layout or the job, not the individual.
Find out where the shortcut goes and why it's quicker. Then either move the walkway or crossing onto that line, or make the dangerous route physically harder with barriers or rails, and guide people to the crossing (HSG136, paragraph 52). Signs alone rarely change it.
They work best when they guide people to a route that is nearly as quick. A barrier that adds a long detour tends to get a gap in it.
Published 20 November 2026 · Last updated 20 November 2026
This piece starts from the ideas set out in How We Think About Safety.
Wondering what a camera would see at your gate? Request a Safety Mapping: one camera, two weeks, at no cost.