Leading indicators for workplace transport: how to choose them and set a tolerance

Part of our workplace transport guide: step 7 of 7

Download the indicator picker (Excel) (XLSX · 7 KB) · Download the indicator picker (Word) (DOCX · 38 KB)

What does HSE say about leading indicators?

HSE's guide to managing for health and safety (HSG65) says to "look for leading indicators as well as lagging indicators. These are also called active and reactive indicators". It explains: "Active methods monitor the design, development, installation and operation of management arrangements. These tend to be preventive in nature".

HSG65 is careful about what counts: "Make sure that your plans have been implemented – 'paperwork' on its own is not a good performance measure." And it is clear where the effort lies: "Selecting the right measures to use is the critical step." Monitoring should also be timely, reach the people who make decisions, and involve the workforce: "Encourage workers to monitor their own work area, reporting any issues they observe."

For workplace transport, HSE's guide (HSG136) adds: "Supervision is an essential part of monitoring safe working." (paragraph 23)

The method, in four steps

HSE's HSG254 sets out a "dual assurance" approach: a lagging indicator to show the outcome, and leading indicators to show the control is working. It was written for process safety, so the examples are about chemical plants, but the logic transfers well to vehicles and people on foot.

  1. Pick the controls that matter most. Start from your risk assessment. Choose the controls you rely on for the worst outcomes: segregation, bay release, lift truck checks. Our risk assessment builder can help you list them.
  2. Name the outcome you're trying to prevent. That is the lagging indicator: for example, vehicle and pedestrian contacts or near misses in a segregated area.
  3. Choose up to two leading indicators on the critical part of the control. HSG254 asks you to "set a leading indicator against each one to show that system is operating as intended" (paragraph 57). Measure the part of the control that actually does the work, not the paperwork around it.
  4. Set a tolerance, and decide in advance what happens when it's breached. "A tolerance should be set for each leading indicator." (paragraph 58) Write down who acts, and what they do.

Worked rows for a site with vehicles

These rows are our example of the method, not HSE's.

Control Lagging indicator Leading indicators
Pedestrian segregation (barriers, walkways, crossings) Contacts or near misses between vehicles and people in segregated areas Barrier and walkway defects fixed within the agreed time; people found outside walkways at the monthly check
Loading bay release (restraint, lights, keys) Drive-away or creep events Bay releases with a complete log; restraints passing the monthly function check
Lift truck pre-use checks (L117, paragraph 162) Incidents linked to truck defects Shifts with a documented check; defects closed on time
Seat restraints on lift trucks (HSG136, paragraphs 217–218) none Spot checks finding seat restraints worn
Visiting driver briefing none Arrivals given the site arrival card

Not every control has a useful lagging indicator. That's fine: some outcomes are too rare to measure month by month, which is exactly why the leading indicators matter.

How to read the results

HSG254 is most useful when the two kinds of indicator disagree.

Near-miss counts need care. A rising count can mean people are reporting more, which is good. Our essay A reporting rate measures trust, not diligence explains why.

A worked example (invented)

This example is invented to show the method. It is not a real site.

A distribution centre's board pack shows lost-time injuries and RIDDOR reports, both low. The new H&S coordinator adds three rows from the table above and agrees tolerances with the operations manager: 95% of bay releases logged, restraint function checks all passed each month, and walkway defects fixed within seven days.

In month two, restraint checks on nights fall below tolerance: two doors haven't been checked. The action agreed in advance kicks in. The night shift manager is asked to complete them that week, and restraint checks are added to the shift handover sheet. In month three, the indicator is back on target.

Real cases

Both show the kind of slow drift that a well-chosen leading indicator is designed to catch. Our essay on how safe sites drift explores why it happens.

Use this: a leading indicator picker

Download the indicator picker (Excel) · Word. Free, no sign-up.

Columns: control, lagging indicator, critical element, leading indicator, data source (for example the monthly check, pre-use sheets, bay logs or the near-miss log), tolerance, owner, and action if out of tolerance. Five rows are filled in from the table above; three are blank for your own controls.

Common questions

What are leading indicators in health and safety?

Measures that show whether your controls are working before anyone is hurt, such as defects fixed on time or checks completed. HSE calls them active indicators. Lagging (reactive) indicators count what has already gone wrong. Our essay on active and reactive monitoring covers the difference.

What are examples of leading indicators for forklift or warehouse safety?

Shifts with a documented pre-use truck check; truck defects closed on time; seat restraints worn at spot checks; walkway and barrier defects fixed within the agreed time; people found outside walkways at monthly checks; bay releases with a complete log.

What is the difference between leading and lagging indicators?

A lagging indicator measures an outcome you want to avoid, such as injuries or near misses. A leading indicator measures whether a control that prevents it is working. HSE asks for both.

How many leading indicators should we have?

Few enough that someone acts on them. HSE's dual-assurance method suggests one lagging indicator and up to two leading indicators for each important control. Five to ten in total is plenty for most sites.

Is near-miss reporting a leading or lagging indicator?

It can be read either way, which is why it needs care. A near miss is an outcome, so it lags; but a rising report count often means people trust the system more, which leads. Track it alongside other measures, not on its own.

How do I set a tolerance for a leading indicator?

Decide what level would worry you enough to act, for example "fewer than 95% of shifts with a documented truck check". Agree it with the person who owns the control, and write down in advance what happens when it's breached. HSG254 asks for a tolerance on every leading indicator.

Sources

Which of your vehicle controls would you most like to show the board is working, before anything goes wrong? Safety Mapping: a free two-week trial on one camera.

Last reviewed November 2026

All guides