Part of our workplace transport guide: step 5 of 7
Download the audit checklist (Word) (DOCX · 38 KB) · Download the audit checklist (PDF) (PDF · 24 KB)
HSE's current guidance doesn't give a single side-by-side definition, so this is ours. A definition quoted online as "the HSE definition of an audit" comes from an older edition of HSE's guide to managing health and safety that has since been replaced.
| Inspection | Audit | |
|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | Are the controls in place today? | Does the system work, and keep working? |
| How often | Frequent: daily, weekly or monthly | Less often: yearly, or after big changes |
| Who does it | Supervisors and staff in the area | Someone independent of the area, internal or external |
| What it looks at | Conditions: barriers, markings, mirrors, lighting, vehicles | Arrangements: the plan, inspections, training, supervision, learning, review |
| Evidence | What you see on the walk | Records, observation at different times, and conversations |
| What it produces | A list of defects to fix | Findings about the system, with actions, owners and dates |
| Traffic management example | "Barrier at crossing 3 damaged" | "Damaged barriers take six weeks to fix and no one tracks it" |
An inspection can tell you a barrier is damaged. An audit asks why it was damaged three times this year and why nobody noticed the pattern.
Active monitoring, including inspections. HSE's guide to managing for health and safety (HSG65) says: "Active methods monitor the design, development, installation and operation of management arrangements." Its first example is "routine inspections of premises, plant and equipment by staff;". Our essay on active and reactive monitoring covers the theory.
Audits where they help. HSG65 says: "In some circumstances formal audits may be useful." HSE's guidance for directors, Leading health and safety at work (INDG417), goes further. It lists "periodic audits of the effectiveness of management structures and risk controls for health and safety" among what a board's monitoring should include, and says: "Larger public and private sector organisations need to have formal procedures for auditing and reporting health and safety performance." It also asks for a yearly look: "The board should review health and safety performance at least once a year."
A legal basis for both. The Management Regulations require arrangements "for the effective planning, organisation, control, monitoring and review of the preventive and protective measures." (regulation 5)
Monitoring that explains, not only counts. HSG65: "Good-quality monitoring will not just identify problems but will help you understand what caused them and what sort of changes are needed to address them." And: "Poor monitoring might tell you that something is wrong but may not help you understand why, or what to do about it." That is the gap an audit fills.
The plan. Is there a current traffic management plan and site map? Do they match the site today: layout, vehicle types, contractors? When were they last reviewed, and what triggered it? See our traffic management plan guide.
Inspections. Are they happening at the planned frequency? Are findings closed, and how fast? Do the same findings keep coming back?
What really happens. HSG136 asks you to "Monitor your workplace activities involving vehicles (including visiting vehicles) over a reasonable period to build up a clear picture of vehicle and pedestrian traffic movements" (paragraph 15). Watch real movements at the peak, at night and at shift change, not only in the daytime.
People. Are drivers authorised and refreshed? Are visiting drivers and agency workers briefed? Is supervision in place? HSG136: "Supervision is an essential part of monitoring safe working." (paragraph 23)
Learning. HSG136: "A clear and simple incident-reporting procedure can help to identify problems early, prevent serious accidents and show how effective your control measures are." (paragraph 22) Pick the last three near misses and follow them through: what changed?
Change. Did the last layout or process change trigger a review of the risk assessment? See our guide to changing a site layout.
Reporting. Who sees the audit result, and what did they decide? HSG65: "The outcome of your monitoring will have most impact if it is reported back to key decision makers in your organisation."
Someone who doesn't run the area, so they see it fresh. That can be a manager from another site or department, or an external auditor. INDG417 asks boards to keep auditors' "cost-effectiveness, independence and objectivity under review."
Watch for the tick-box trap. HSG65: "You need to be sure that your monitoring adds value and isn’t just a tick-box exercise." An audit that reuses the inspection checklist will find what the inspections already found.
INDG417 also asks: "How well do you know what is happening on the ground, and what audits or assessments are undertaken to inform you about what your organisation and contractors actually do?" A good audit answers that question honestly.
INDG417 says the board "should ensure that any audit is perceived as a positive management and boardroom tool." An audit that finds gaps is doing its job.
This example is invented to show the method. It is not a real site.
A port terminal's monthly inspections have passed every month this year. An audit by the H&S lead from another terminal finds:
| Finding | Evidence | Action |
|---|---|---|
| The traffic management plan predates the new reach stacker route | Plan dated two years ago; the route opened in spring | Update the plan and site map; brief all shifts |
| The night shift uses a crossing that isn't on the plan | Observed at 2 am; worn markings | Assess the crossing; mark it or close it |
| Two near misses at the same corner led to no change | Near-miss log; no action recorded | Review the corner; reply to both reporters |
| Inspection findings take weeks to close | Defect log | Set a close-out time and report it monthly |
In September 2026, a scrap metal company in Scunthorpe was fined £40,000 after a father and son unloading scrap were injured when part of a stockpile collapsed while an excavator worked nearby. HSE's press release reports that this followed an earlier near miss on 27 January 2025 involving the same excavator, and that "the underlying failures were the same". A near miss that is recorded but doesn't prompt a look at the system is the kind of gap an audit is there to catch. (HSE press release)
Download the audit checklist (Word) · PDF. Free, no sign-up.
It follows the sections above: the plan, inspections, what really happens, people, learning, change, reporting and independence. For each question there are columns for the evidence you looked at, the finding, and the action, owner and date.
An inspection checks conditions and controls in one area at a point in time, such as barriers, markings and vehicles. An audit checks whether the whole system works and keeps working: whether plans are current, inspections happen and findings close, rules are followed at all hours, and lessons lead to change. Inspections are frequent and local; audits are less frequent and look at the system.
There is no general legal duty to carry out something called an "audit". But the Management Regulations require arrangements for "the effective planning, organisation, control, monitoring and review of the preventive and protective measures", and HSE's guidance for directors says larger organisations "need to have formal procedures for auditing and reporting health and safety performance."
HSE's guidance doesn't set a fixed interval. A yearly audit fits HSE's advice that boards should review performance at least once a year. Audit sooner after a significant change, a serious incident, or a run of similar near misses.
Someone independent of the area being audited, so they see it with fresh eyes. That can be a competent person from elsewhere in the organisation or an external auditor. HSE's guidance for directors asks for auditors' independence and objectivity to be kept under review.
The traffic management plan and site map; whether inspections happen and findings close; observation of real movements at the peak, at night and at shift change; driver authorisation and briefing; how near misses lead to change; whether changes trigger reviews; and who receives the result.
Yes. HSE inspectors can visit workplaces and can take enforcement action. That is a different meaning of "inspection" from your own checks. Our guide to HSE investigations, notices and fines explains what happens.
Your inspections say the controls are in place. Do you know they work at 3 am? Safety Mapping: a free two-week trial on one camera.
Last reviewed November 2026